[Users] Mailing list replies - Was: Error while sending....

[Ralf Mardorf]

On Mon, 26 Jan 2015 13:09:05 +0100, Ralf Mardorf wrote:
> On Mon, 26 Jan 2015 10:48:05 +0100, Stephan Braun wrote:
> > Mahlzeit!
> > 
> > On 26.01.2015 at 07:09:39 Ralf Mardorf <info.mardorf at rocketmail.com>
> > wrote:
> > If you reply TO somebody and CC to the mailing list, Claws _can't_
> > >automatically reply to the mailing list only, even when
> > >Configuration > Preferences... > Writing > Reply button invokes
> > >mailing list reply is checked. The OP sent a message TO me and
> > >CC'ed to the mailing list. I explained that this is wrong. JFTR,
> > >there's the same problem for Claws, if somebody has an entry for
> > >Reply-To.
> > 
> > Ralf, you are mixing up mails…
> > 
> > In the case a mail was sent To: you and Cc: list, you should have
> > received two messages: one directly to you and one via the list.
> > 
> > What you did was to reply to the message that was sent directly to
> > you. Because of this, the message was lacking all the relevant list
> > headers so Claws could not have any chance to know, that it should
> > trigger a list reply. Please check the headers of the message you
> > replied to. I'm sure you won't find something like 
> > "List-Id: <users.lists.claws-mail.org>"
> 
> That is nonsense, I don't want to receive duplicated messages, so for
> all for mailman lists I'm subscribed, such as this list, I enabled:
> 
> "Avoid duplicate copies of messages?
> 
> When you are listed explicitly in the To: or Cc: headers of a list
> message, you can opt to not receive another copy from the mailing
> list. Select Yes to avoid receiving copies from the mailing list;
> select No to receive copies.
> 
> If the list has member personalized messages enabled, and you elect to
> receive copies, every copy will have a X-Mailman-Copy: yes header
> added to it."
> 
> I only received one mail and I'm not willing to change my mailman
> settings, so that I need to receive duplicates.
> 
> It's simply true that I didn't make a mistake. It's simply wrong to Cc
> to mailing lists. Period.
> 
> Regards,
> Ralf

And yes, if the Cc'ed mail is sent from list a reply works, assumed a
sender didn't use Reply-To, then it doesn't work anymore. As pointed
out earlier, a mail directly send _to me_ and/or Reply-To messages can
be replied to the mailing list _only_ by one click when e.g. using
Evolution. It's not a mistake when Claws can't handle this, but since
it's a Claw's mailing list I thought it would be ok to friendly give
the hint, that we shouldn't Cc to the list, but only send _to_ the
list. I can't understand that now everybody is that hostile against me.