[Users] [Bug 3889] address and quoted message inconsistent in reply

[Paul]

On Tue, 18 Sep 2018 13:50:15 +0200
Michal Suchánek <msuchanek at suse.de> wrote: 

> AFAICT claws does not have per-list reply settings so I use
> reply-all all the time which works with all lists.

See /Comfiguration/Preferences/Compose/Writing, 'Reply invokes
mailing list reply'.

See /Message/Reply to/Mailing List.

See /Message/Mailing List/...

Failing those, you can create a folder for a mailing list, filter the
messages into it, and then use the Folder Properties to set the
correct address.

> It fixes sending mail to random people unrelated to the message
> which can be considered security issue. On the other hand it breaks
> some features in an obvious and easy to workaround way. I would say
> it's an improvement.

That's where we differ. It's not about sending messages, but about
composing them. Arguably, the current situation is easy to avoid.
Sure it improves one thing and breaks 2 others, that makes a score of
-1 to me :) Since we know that your patch breaks things, it can't
possibly be accepted.

Anyway, Colin's patch is getting close to fixing it, (it also doesn't
break anything), some more work and it will be good.

with regards

Paul