[Users] Filtering spam difference - auto v. manual

[wwp]

Hello Pierre,


On Sat, 28 Oct 2017 10:34:45 -0400 Pierre Fortin <pf at pfortin.com> wrote:

> Hi guys,
> 
> Hope I'm not missing something obvious; but I recently created a top
> level domain (TLD) filter to catch some spam messages which are not yet
> learned by spamd -- it colors these messages to distinguish them from msgs
> processed automatically by spamd.
> 
> The incoming messages are filtered as expected, and moved to my SPAM
> folder; but if I get a message with a new TLD sourcing mostly spam, I add
> the new TLD to the rule, then manually run 'Tools->Filter selected
> messages' on the new msg. Everything occurs as expected, except for the
> move to the SPAM folder -- both auto and manual filter log entries are
> identical, ending with:
> [10:18:35] processing rule 'SPAM-tld' [ from regexpcase ".bid>" | from
> regexpcase ".date>" | from regexpcase ".download>" | from regexpcase
> ".stream>" | from regexpcase ".top>" | from regexpcase ".trade>" | from  
> regexpcase ".tv>" color 7 mark_as_spam move "#mh/Mailbox/inbox/SPAM" ]
> [10:18:35] checking if message matches [ from regexpcase ".bid>" ]
> [10:18:35] checking if message matches [ from regexpcase ".date>" ]
> [10:18:35] checking if message matches [ from regexpcase ".download>" ]
> [10:18:35] checking if message matches [ from regexpcase ".stream>" ]
> [10:18:35] checking if message matches [ from regexpcase ".top>" ]
> > message matches  
> [10:18:35] applying action [ color 7 ]
> [10:18:35] applying action [ mark_as_spam ]
> 
> 
>    Aside: I was careful to make move the last action; but I see in the
>    --debug log that sa-learn is called, so the move is redundant. I know I
>    can just hit the Spam button which will move the message to SPAM; but
>    manually filtering was to ensure my filter was correct.
> 
> Any reason for the move not to occur when manually filtering?  Bug?

I'd say that, if an action is not reached, it's because the previous
one either discards the selection (email not there anymore) or returns
something that means to stop the actions list.

Could we see the actions list? I'm not sure 


Regards,

-- 
wwp
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 836 bytes
Desc: OpenPGP digital signature
URL: <http://lists.claws-mail.org/pipermail/users/attachments/20171028/91963bb5/attachment.sig>